Reflections On Hiroshi Sugimoto’s Hirshhorn

In 2017, Hiroshi Sugimoto told the Japan Society he has a “stone fetish”; the Hirshhorn Sculpture Garden is proof.

the l shaped stone walls in the sunken sculpture garden frame bronze sculptures by rodin and are interspersed by vibrant red leafed trees. the cylindrical concrete form of the hirshhorn museum fills the upper left corner of the photo, while the lower right is crossed by the wide rough aggregate concrete wall surrounding the garden
Hammered aggregate, Maine granite, Chinese pavers, and The Burghers of Calais in Hiroshi Sugimoto’s redesigned Hirshhorn Sculpture Garden

After recently following the photographer, sculptor, antique collector, and Noh aficionado’s concerning statements glorifying civilization’s lost past, I was very concerned for what Sugimoto’s redesign of a Modernist landscape attached to a Brutalist museum on the National Mall in the midst of a fascist ascendancy might portend. So when I say it could have been worse, I don’t mean it could have been much, much worse—though it really could have.

the barrel of the hirshhorn museum is situated between and behind a space in angled dry stack style stone walls in the sunken sculpture garden in front of it. a red leafed tree is also between the two wall sections, and in the foreground some journalists mingle. the sky is blue, the effect is basically not kitsch
ヒルシュホルン城?

My fears since the stone-based project was first announced like six years ago was that Sugimoto was either going to reskin the garden’s concrete walls with stone—or stone veneer, like the worst, most upscale Tuscan strip mall in Camarillo. Or that he was going to turn the Hirshhorn into a kitschy Brutalist Japanese castle with the sunken garden remade as its ersatz stone foundation. into the I mean, it is, in fact, fine. It’s even nice.

a middle aged white guy blogger took this selfie in the curved, striated mirror finish of a stainless steel wall, one of two lining the passageway under the road between the sculpture garden, reflected at left, and the hirshhorn museum, which is to the right
Vertical striations in the steel panels of Sugimoto’s Passage probably value engineered an order of magnitude of savings on fabrication and installation, and probably mitigating the fingerprints that are sure to come
a bronze sculpture cast from a cardboard box has all the web of vents and channels for casting still attached. it sits on a plinth in a planted bed in a concrete and rough granite walled sculpture garden on a sunny morning
Mark Grotjahn, Untitled, 2014, and the bronze casting apparatus it came in on, a 2025 gift of the artist

The Hirshhorn is officially calling Sugimoto’s redesign a “revitalization,” which, in a more just world, should underscore the way the museum and the Smithsonian let the sculpture garden degrade so far and for so long. But Sugimoto and his collaborators really should get more credit for their significant reconfiguration of the garden’s flow, access, and surfaces; and the outdoor exhibition spaces, while somehow maintaining a sense of continuity with the garden’s origins and past.

the rough aggregate steps, ledge on the planters, and benches of the modernist sculpture garden have the names of the canadian billionaire, his wife, and his rent-a-cop company, engraved on them. the long stones of the plaza in the foreground are from china, torn up in that country's modernization, and preserved here by a japanese artist turned architect, with a stone fetish in the background, below some trees, are two large white blobby sculptures.
POV: you’re a trustee and you buy naming opportunities for yourself AND your private security company

And Sugimoto’s stone fetish is instrumental in that success. The original [sic] concrete walls of the sunken sculpture garden have been remade/resurfaced/roughed up with a more textured aggregate that feels vintage, but is not. They define the garden’s modernist structure.

a photo over the parapet-like edge of the wall surrounding the sunken sculpture garden includes the top of a freestanding stone wall, and the large biomorphic bronze creature sculpture on a round pedestal which stands in front of it. the same miro is at moma and the solow collection, the guy who owns 9 west 57th st in nyc
Don’t touch: Sugimoto’s freestanding, clearly not dry stacked stone wall framing a Miro

The drystack-style, angled stone walls that are Sugimoto’s major intervention stand just free of this historic(ized) concrete and define the garden’s “rooms” for displaying sculpture. An experienced artist is an unsurprisingly sensitive producer of space for viewing art. And the stone (Maine granite) is a beautiful backdrop for the Hirshhorn’s foundational collection of 20th century modern bronzes [The first inhabitants of these rooms are big works by Moore, Hepworth, and Rodin.]

several journalists mill about an open space in a sunken sculpture garden, with a rough stone wall on two sides of a central planter bed in which stands a rodin of seven grim and raggedly looking male figures. the journalists all seem fine. in the foreground in another planter bed, is a smaller rodin of a single human figure curled up in a ball, or a very uncomfortable seating situation
Unidentified press in the Rodin “room” with carefully cultivated plantings by Smithsonian Gardens.

But Sugimoto’s fetish is not finished. Stones “from the artist’s personal collection” mark the bed of Yoko Ono’s Wishing Tree. And the entire garden is covered with vintage, elongated paving stones Sugimoto salvaged from torn up Chinese streets, which he arranged and numbered for color and balance [in a precisely designed randomness that mirrors the placement of Olafur Eliasson’s quasibricks on the courtyard walls of a Tadao Ando-designed guest house.] They unify the rooms on the east, the central plazas and pools, and the larger, grassy space on the west. which will be the site of a rotating monumental sculpture commission. Right now it’s Yoshitomo Nara.

Sugimoto’s own monumental sculpture is permanent. Passage of Reflectance (2026, Hirshhorn accession number 2026.001) echoes in plan the conical mathematical forms Sugimoto first photographed in plaster, and later recreated in mirrored steel. Here two walls of rippled, mirror-finish steel whose curves converge on a point at the center of the museum line the passageway from the garden to the museum plaza.

a middle aged white guy with a blog and a grey sweater jacket takes a selfie at a point where two curved mirrored walls of an artwork converge, so there are five other reflections of him receding into the mirrors. to the right is the edge of a mirrored panel, and light from a concrete tunnel passageway. big beautiful paving stones are from china which i really hope doesn't become a problem

With a program of shiny objects, selfies, and spectacle concocted under the attendance delirium of a Kusama Infinity Rooms exhibition, the museum’s ludicrous stated goal—of attracting 3 million visitors/year, roughly 10% of the 34 million people who set foot on the Mall, a 600% increase on the museum’s 2025 attendance, and roughly the same number of visitors as the National Air & Space Museum gets, in two locations—still doesn’t make sense, but you can see how we got what we did.

two men stand next to a pathway and square platform at the center of two shallow pools which all together form a larger square composition at the center of a stone plaza. steps down to the plaza are at the bottom of the photo, and trees and the far wall of a sculpture garden are at the top.
the Lehrman4 Pools on GardaWorld Plaza: the dimensions of the pool on the left echo the original, which in turn echo the window/balcony on the Hirshhorn’s façade.

And Sugimoto is at the center, literally. At the center of the Noh-inspired stage, at the center of the pool, on the garden and museum’s central axis, sits Sugimoto’s own sculpture, Mathematical Model 029
Kuen’s surface: a surface with constant negative curvature
(2026), a split boulder pierced by a precisely voluptuous attenuation of mirrored steel that feels like the flayed skin of Brancusi’s Bird in Space turned inside out.

a photo from the center of the hirshhorn garden pool lines up with the center of a stone and steel sculpture on a platform in the pool, but it is slightly to the left of center of the large white peanut shaped pool sculpture on the far side of the sunken garden. this initially caused great stress or confusion
the moment where it all doesn’t line up

Which turns out to be the point of inflection for the entire site. The Sculpture Garden is aligned with the National Mall, which is rotated one degree from the street grid the museum is aligned with. Elmgreen & Dragset’s pool (sculpture) is thus on axis with the National Archives across the Mall, but not Sugimoto’s passageway south of the pool (water feature).

a photo from the center platform of the hirshhorn garden pool, centered on the mirror finish convoluted and elongated steel sculpture embedded in a large dark boulder, is aligned with the center of the curved mirrored passageway underneath a rough concrete wall, that leads to the large concrete barrel shaped museum beyond.
this Noh stage-shaped stage is set to be used for performances, but not (yet) actual Noh.

This is only apparent, though, within the sunken garden. and until it was explained to me by two of the project’s architects, I assumed it was, like so much else in this town, a manifestation of the concealed insanity of the center.

three giant white painted aluminum blob sculptures are blown up from tiny palm sized clay doodads, and now plopped on a green lawn in the hirshhorn museum's sunken sculpture garden. off the lawn but in the center of the photo is a sandstone or limestone looking sculptural column by an artist who should be filling the lawn instead.
three Nara sculptures in painted aluminum cast from little hand-size blobs made during the pandemic, a Lauren Halsey column, and a KAWS head on the left. Not seen: the Raven Halfmon, the Huma Babha or the Liz Larner.

The museum’s plaza is hollow, and cannot support the weight of large sculptures, or the equipment needed to readily move mid-scale sculptures around. So the sculpture garden offers the Hirshhorn the first real opportunity to exhibit monumental works—and they put in three blown up, blobby clay heads by Yoshitomo Nara and a KAWS. Unbelievable. The Naras, at least, will rotate.

metal barricades partially block the entrance to a rough concrete staircase leading down under the street from the plaza of the hirshhorn museum. a crane and other construction equipment linger on the side

A major objective of the garden “revitalization” was accessibility: from the Mall to the garden, and from the garden to the museum. Sugimoto’s Passage leads to a stairway that opens directly onto the museum’s plaza, which is, on the Mall side, on a plinth several shallow steps above the street. The reopened underground passageway was closed as part of the garden’s last redesign, in 1981. It is obviously all steps.

a presentation slide from the hirshhorn museum diagrams the proposal to renovate the museum's plaza and to connect its lower level with double entrances from the newly renovated sculpture garden. presented sept 2026
Slide showing the original project scope for a lower level entrance to the Museum [aahp.si.edu]

This mall-to-museum flow is central to the Hirshhorn’s visitor goals, and it completely punts on accessibility. As recently as September, the Smithsonian still presented the garden and passageway connecting directly to the museum’s lower level, something a museum representative told me this week was not in the cards.

a photo of the center of the hirshhorn museum's round plaza, with its dark bronze circular fountain turned off, and the glassed in lobby on the far side between two massive concrete piers. 2.5 levels of glass windows in a concrete mullioned grid loom over it all

Though it is mentioned, and would be crucial for handling a 6-fold increase of visitors from the Mall, this lower level entrance is not as important for the museum’s next facilities renovation proposal, undergoing Section 106 review for its impact on the National Mall Historic District, as the push to expand the museum’s current lobby on three sides, beyond its original footprint.

a slide from a sept 2026 presentation by the hirshhorn museum to expand the lobby beyond and around the two massive concrete piers that flank it. a small diagram of such is next to a large photo of some visitors milling about underneath the concrete donut shaped museum, in front of a temporary entrance vestibule installed for the museum's blockbuster kusama exhibition, but dismantled after visitor numbers returned to normal.

This flood of new visitors cannot be accommodated, the museum argues, by the single revolving door and single security line on the lobby’s south side, and the lobby’s failure to handle the museum’s current 500,000 visitors proves it.

a presentation slide from sept 2026 by the hirshhorn listing a bunch of problems with the museum's lobby, almost all of which are self-made, contradictory, temporary, or exaggerated, it's like, we turned our entire lobby from a corporate event rental space into an artist designed espresso bar and now we can't fit anything else, help we've tried nothing

The most recent public presentation claims circulation in the lobby is too constrained for Smithsonian-recommended security protocols, too small for events, and too crowded to accommodate art installations. This claim ignores the fact that in 2012, the museum’s store, which used to stand at the center of the lobby, was moved to the lower lobby, so it could become a conceptual element of the Barbara Kruger vinyl wrap installation which continues to cover the rest of the space. This cleared the lobby for use—and rent—as an event space. In 2017, the lobby’s open space and the information desk were repurposed into an artwork—an espresso bar, café tables, and benches—by Hiroshi Sugimoto.

the artwork that is the hirshhorn lobby with a bronze scale clad coffee and gelato bar in the background, and two tables made from the bisected trunk and root complex of a 700 year old nutmeg tree with glass on top, and curved petal-like grey upholstered chairs around them, all by hiroshi sugimoto and co
The internet may have been a library and is now a store, but the Hirshhorn lobby used to be a store, and then it became a café, while telling the accountants it’s an artwork

These artist interventions enabled Hirshhorn and Smithsonian leadership to use restricted art acquisition funds for capital projects.

My idea was to transform the Hirshhorn’s Lobby into an artwork that symbolizes what is unique about both the building and the collection. Ideally, this piece is sculpture, furniture, and conceptual art, all at the same time.
—Hiroshi Sugimoto

But while Sugimoto’s lobby was touted as art, and it spent art’s money, the museum does not officially treat it as art. The registrar has not entered it into the collection. The museum is not required to care for it in the same way. And it is not constrained from changing, deaccessioning, or even destroying it.

Though it has been officially accessioned, I expect that Sugimoto’s Passage served a similar accounting purpose, unlocking an outsized portion of the budget for a project that cannot technically be called a renovation. By involving an artist and incorporating an artwork in their garden renovation [sic], museum officials transmuted questions of building or historic preservation into matters of art acquisition and exhibition, over which they could claim more authority with fewer outside checks.

All of these sleights of hand have been enacted by a decade-plus of Hirshhorn and Smithsonian museum leaders who have been given the benefit of the doubt—or, in the case of Richard Koshalek, given the boot after he alienated the local philanthropists who held the whole, weak board together.

But now, months before cutting the ribbon on what was probably the top bullet point on her LinkedIn, Melissa Chiu has yeeted herself to the Guggenheim, leaving the Hirshhorn with an acting director and a stripped down exhibition calendar. The Smithsonian itself is under sustained attack, its trustees’ terms expiring unfilled, and its secretary heading for the exits. At a moment of substantive accomplishment, the museum and the Institution behind it feel more precarious than ever.

Previously, related: ‘It is now possible to detail each stone in CAD’
‘The most believable stone veneers in the world’
‘And what do you do, Mr. Ando?’