Portrait in Time of Mammy Prater

a photo portrait of anna "mammy" prater, circa 1920, from the library of congress, depicts the 115-year-old Black woman with a strong, weathered face and haunting eyes looking off to the left of the camera, sitting in a rocking chair outside, a house and shrubbery out of focus in the background. prater wears a thin white bonnet, a dark crocheted shawl over a white dress. her hands rest on her lap at the bottom right corner of the photo, where she holds a small white paper bag and some candies. via the library of congress
photo of Annie “Mammy” Prater, c. 1920, probably by the LA Times, via LOC

From her conversation with Saidiya Hartman, I learned about Dionne Brand’s poem, first published in 1990, “Blues Spiritual for Mammy Prater,” which is a response to a c. 1920 photograph of a 115-year-old formerly enslaved woman in Los Angeles:

what jumped out at me was how Mammy Prater’s figure in the photograph exuded a weight and patience, a knowledge about a future time when something might be recognized in the photograph. The poem talks about how she waited for her century to turn, until the technology of photography was ready to capture this something. It seemed to me that the statement she conveyed through the photograph was waiting to be understood by us in much later years. It could be understood in her time, but not sufficiently—not in in a way that could repay that pose. Only in the future could that pose be repaid by an understanding of what it took to sit there and be there.

Though the Library of Congress has several photos of her, most of the understanding of Prater today is due to Brand’s evocative poem. The only substantive account of Prater’s story I can find is on author Kimberly Tilley’s blog, Old Spirituals. She seems to recap an uncited 1920 article in the Los Angeles times about a US Census worker interviewing Prater on a farm in Los Angeles, and being shocked by her reported birth year: 1805. The story somehow involves a visit by J[ames] B[radley] Law, a descendant of the Darlington, South Carolina planter who enslaved Prater, who corroborated her stories and claims. The LOC’s photos have the upbeat, patronizing captions of the newspaper: “Mammy Prater, a 115-year-old ex-slave who is still hale and hearty.” “One hundred and fifteen years have failed to dim the keen eyesight of [Mammy Prater] this ex-slave” “Age has not dimmed Mammy Prater’s love for sweets.” Other images from the same shoot circulate in the stock photo archives.

henry g fitz jr's 1840 self portrait is probably the first photo of an american. the head of a white man in his 30s is photographed in three quarters view. he has dark short hair, and no beard. his eyes and mouth are closed in a still, but slightly tensed way. his high collar and coat obscure his neck. the image, on a copper plate, is dark, and speckled all over with white spots from the rudimentary chemical process. and perhaps its 180 year-old age. from the smithsonian
Henry G. Fitz, Jr., Self-portrait, prob early 1840, 80×60 mm Smithsonian, National Museum of American History via The Art Newspaper

Prater was 35 when the first photographic portrait of an American was made in 1840, a self-portrait by Henry G. Fitz, Jr. of Baltimore, who kept his eyes closed during the long exposure time required of the Daguerreotype process. [It was just discussed on The Week in Art, because it is on loan from the Smithsonian National Museum of American History to a Rijksmuseum exhibition of American photography.]

Prater was 13 when Frederick Douglass was born in 1818. Douglass, of course, escaped slavery and went on to make himself the most photographed person in the 19th century. Isaac Julien’s 2019 multi-channel portrait, Lessons of the Hour—Frederick Douglass, includes several scenes of him making photographs. It’s on view at the Smithsonian through 2026. When Douglass died in 1895, Prater was just 85.

Aunt Mary, a 1935 photo by Charles Sheeler, shows Mary Brown, an elderly Black woman in a 19th century bonnet, dress, and apron, sitting in a windsor chair at a desk in a colonial era kitchen, a large fireplace over her right shoulder, and an array of copper ladles over the desk on her left. a brass candlestick sits next to her arm, as does the wrapper for a loaf of bread from contemporary richmond, virginia
Charles Sheeler, Aunt Mary, 1941, deaccessioned from the Museum of Modern Art in 2018, image via Christie’s

Prater was 60 when Mary Brown was born in 1865. Brown would be photographed 70 years later by Charles Sheeler, while she was dressed as “Aunt Mary,” a fictionalized enslaved cook she portrayed when she worked as one of the few Black performers at the Rockefellers’ Colonial Williamsburg in 1935-36.

When the Works Progress Administration began to gather more than 2,300 first-hand accounts and over 500 photo portraits Born in Slavery: Slave Narratives from the Federal Writers Project, 1936-38, Prater would have been 131. By that point, though, was through waiting.

Two Interviews With Dionne Brand About Salvage

Our oldest had to read Mansfield Park in 9th grade and very much did not like it, and so I’ve avoided it. Until I heard poet Dionne Brand talking about it with David Naimon on the Tin House podcast, Between The Covers. [youtube] Brand’s latest book, Salvage: Readings From The Wreck, is a forensic return to a whole host of “classic” texts, including Austen’s Mansfield Park, that find Blackness where it has been omitted by the structures of colonialism, imperialism, and slavery. But Brand goes beyond literary analysis to question the function of a novel, and how forms of writing—and thus thinking—perpetuate and protect the structures that spawned them.

Anyway, now I just read another conversation between Brand and Saidiya Hartman, from Bomb Magazine last fall. Here they discuss the larger goal outlined in Salvage:

[Dionne Brand] I’m rereading these texts with the hope of abandoning them as aesthetic objects. When these texts were written, they were done so self-consciously as colonial objects. If they were being made as aesthetic objects, they were for the European bourgeoisie. In fact, these texts were created and encouraged because they told readers about the wonderful life that slave-owning, the eradication of Indigenous peoples, and violence allowed.

[Saidiya Hartman] I really like that formulation: to reread these texts with the hope of abandoning them as aesthetic objects. Salvage clearly articulates the ways in which a colonial project, a settler project, even when it does not announce itself explicitly and politically, finds refuge in the categories of the aesthetic and the beautiful.

Even if I hadn’t heard Brand’s conversation, I like to think I’d have spotted the glaring anxieties of capitalism that obsess almost every character in Mansfield Park, as well as the many references to Antigua and, thus, the direct dependence on plantation slavery of the family’s fortunes—and their entire world. I’m only halfway through, and this book [Austen obv] is grim as hell.

Brand’s not through, though. Her and Hartman’s discussion of photography, visual art, aesthetics, and beauty continues to work away in my mind.

[meanwhile, in case you needed any evidence that this conversation happened in September: “Soon that phrase will be outlawed in the States. (laughter)

Dionne Brand: Salvage: Readings From The Wreck [tinhouse]
Dionne Brand interviewed by Saidiya Hartman [bombmagazine]

Talking Siena at The Brooklyn Rail

Mark Leckey’s conversation with Charlotte Kent organized by the Brooklyn Rail brought the Siena show at the Met back to my mind today.

Which led me back a few weeks to a conversation between Siena curator Stephan Wolohojian and BR contributing editor Alex Nagel. Wolohojian was also the curator of Manet/Degas.

Among other things they talk about seeing “the other side” of these rarely moved panel paintings, a subject that’s always welcome here.

what the brooklyn rail's alex nagel calls the other side, or verso, of the walker art gallery, liverpool's simone martini painting of teen jesus getting in trouble with mary and joseph for going to the temple, but that's not what is photographed here. this side has the engaged frame, built in, and has a reddish swirl with black and greys, a simulation of a fantastical grain of stone, but all in paint. there are also four labels slapped rather unceremoniously onto the painted surface, but those hadn't been seen for over 150 years, and no one at the museum even knew what this looked like from the back until it was loaned to the met, where this pic was taken in december 2024
my pic is a little clearer than the slide on zoom: “the other side” of Simone Martini’s Christ Discovered in the Temple, once apparently titled, Joseph and The Virgin remonstrating with [the] Savior on his return from the temple.

Some were painted to resemble a fantastical stone, like Simone Martini’s Christ Discovered in the Temple, from the Walker Art Gallery in Liverpool. Another, a Martini borrowed somehow from the Gardner Museum, was finished in silver.

the back, or other side, as the brooklyn rail's alex nagel puts it, of the isabella stewart gardner museum's smaller simone martini painting is shown in this photo by the metropolitan museum to be finished in silver, incised all over with intricate patterns like the gold sections on the front and frame, except silver tarnishes to a darker mottled grey over 600 years so

Alex was a great editor and sounding board last year when I wrote a piece for the Rail on art & autocracy. Hard to imagine now how I ever thought that’d be a relevant subject.

Forbidden Colors, NFL (2025)

During Kendrick's halftime show a man unfurled a Palestinian flag and was chased off stage and eventually tackled and removed by security.

Read the book Abolish Rent (@jphillll.bsky.social) 2025-02-10T02:04:22.930Z

The first video I saw of the dancer in the Super Bowl halftime show breaking the choreography and unfurling a Palestinine/Sudan flag is still the most jarring. He runs around unimpeded with his flag, joining the crowd of flag wavers during Kendrick Lamar’s performance, and you can imagine him hatching plan in rehearsal. Seeing the A Minor flags, and Lamar’s mic drop ending where he stands amid a field of Black men in red, white, and blue gear, forming a giant American flag around him, and asking, “What flags are missing? Which flags aren’t being raised at this moment that should be?”

screenshot of a video from the superbowl halftime show depicting two agent smith type security agents in dark suits grabbing a dancer holding a palestine/sudan flag, about to tackle him to the ground on the edge of the football field. in the foreground are a couple dozen more dancers in formation, wearing red white and blue sweatsuits, waiting for their cue to start stepping. another dancer with a large black flag depicting the white silhouette of two little children reaching toward a capital a, a sign for A Minor, from kendrick lamar's not like us, posted to bluesky by jphillll

The chill comes from the end, though, where suited security agents tackle him while a grid of focused dancers continue their stepping in the foreground.

The next morning, the AP’s report of the incident, which did not make it onto the main broadcast, said the individual had been detained by New Orleans police while “law enforcement is working to determine applicable charges in this incident.”

[a few minutes later update: no charges, and a lifetime ban from the NFL.]

@jphillll.bsky.social [bsky.app]
Gonzalez-Torres Forbidden Colors, May 2021—

Gerhard Richter, Viral Artist

a blattecke print by gerhard richter depicting a painting of a curled corner of a sheet of paper, used by the artist as note paper in 1969. he wrote to his dealer august haseke that he was delivering 101 more signed copies of the edition, which were infected by his cold, which he tried to spread evenly across all the sheets. this sheet and one other used for notes were included in the auction of haseke's estate at lempertz in 2018, but did not sell.

And here I thought that Gerhard Richter’s critique of the art market by making an offset print in an open edition was surpassed only by his using the prints as note paper. Claudio Santambrogio is much better than I at deciphering Richter’s handwriting, and he figured out the entire note Richter wrote to his dealer August Haseke in November 1969 when he finally delivered the first half of his 1967 open edition, Blattecke. And it is a whole new art direction casting its shadow:

Lieber August,
Hier sind heute endlich 101 Stück (Nr 286-386).
Jetzt liegen noch ca. 350 Stück hier; zu Deiner Information.
Ich bin so erkältet, dass ich die 101 Stück gut signieren konnte. Ich 
habe mich bemüht, die Viren gleichmäßig über die Blätter zu verteilen.
(Die nächsten 50 hoffe ich mit etwas schickeren Viren infiltrieren zu 
können, vielleicht Tollwut oder so was).
Eine ganz neue Kunstrichtung wirft ihre Schatten.
Alle gute Euch
herzliche Grüße
Dein Gerhard


Dear August,
Here are finally 101 pieces today (nos. 286-386).
Now there are still about 350 pieces here; for your information.
I have such a cold, I could sign 101 pieces. I have tried to 
distribute the viruses evenly over the sheets.
(I hope to infiltrate the next 50 with some fancier viruses, maybe rabies 
or something).
A whole new art direction is casting its shadow.
All the best to you
best regards
Your Gerhard

expanding brain meme with four stages: 1) GERHARD RICHTER UNDERMINING THE ART 
MARKET BY: MAKING  AN OFFSET
PRINT OF A PHOTO OF A PAINTING
AS AN OPEN
EDITION; 2) STARTING WITH 739, 
NOW AT 906+; 3) USING THE PRINTS
AS NOTE PAPER;
4) TURNING THEM INTO A VIRAL VECTOR BY SIGNING THEM ALL WHILE HE WAS SICK

This is not what I envisioned when I mentioned a Felix-like stack, and yet the shadow is cast.

[week later update: these notes and additional related material are now in the Richter Archive in Dresden. Apparently it took Richter three years to work his way through signing the first 739 Blattecke.]

Previously, related: There Are At Least 906 Blattecke
Stack(Ed.)
When Form Becomes Content, or Luanda: Encyclopedic City, On The Stack as Medium

Wayne Bremser on Eggleston’s Slideshows

white guy in a wassily chair in david zwirner's la gallery taking a picture of a slideshow of william eggleston photos. the slide projected on the wall is of another white guy in a taupe suit sitting on an orange cushioned rocking sofa on a paved patio surrounded by a trellis, a 1970 photo taken of eggleston by a family friend using his camera, via wayne bremser

Wayne Bremser has a fascinating tumblr post about William Eggleston’s use of slideshows to exhibit his color photography before he figured out a successful way to print it. Eggleston has been generally credited, along with Stephen Shore, of bringing color photography into the fine art world. But Bremser also gives an important shoutout to Helen Levitt, who was showing her color photos of NYC two years earlier at MoMA—as a slideshow.

The impetus was a show at David Zwirner LA of Eggleston’s “Last Dyes,” the vintage prints using a long-discontinued dye transfer process. Dye Transfer is a whole journey in itself; for me the culminating color achievement of the dwindling print technology was early Liz Deschenes’ monochrome photos. I have not seen a Liz Deschenes slideshow.

Eggleston’s Slideshows [bremser.tumblr.com]
Previously, related: Apparently, Bill Levitt’s Sister Was Something of A Photographer
Later, related: Liz Deschenes showing new dye transfers at the George Eastman Museum

There Are At Least 906 Blattecke

gerhard richter's 1967 edition blattecke, sheet corner, is a photo of a painting depicting a curled up lower right corner of a sheet of cream colored paper that is white on the back. it casts shadow on the surface below it, and richter signs and dates each edition in this "underneath" spot, with the number of the edition written on the corner of the curved sheet. this is no. 555 of an original edition of 739, btw, but we'll get into that.
no. 555/739+ of Gerhard Richter’s Blattecke, 1967, sold by a consumer in 2024 at Christie’s

Happy belated Blattecke Tag to all who celebrate. 6.2.67, Februrary 6th, 1967, the date Gerhard Richter signed on most of the 739 examples of Blattecke (Sheet Corner) [Ed. CR 11], the 1967 offset print edition based on a full-scale photo of a little 1965 painting, Umgeschlagenes Blatt (Turned Sheet) [CR 70-2], which was 24 x 18 cm.

739 seems like a pretty big edition already, but Richter conceived of the edition as open and unlimited. How open and how unlimited is not clear. Richter’s website only mentions two additional examples, one dated 15.5.97, bringing the total to 741.

an example of gerhard richter's 1967 edition blattecke, sheet corner, a print of a photo of a painting depicting a curled up lower right corner of a sheet of cream colored paper that is white on the back. it casts shadow on the surface below it, where richter signed and dated this one 11.2.2017, and numbered it 906 on the curled sheet, selling in feb 2025 at grisebach
Gerhard Richter, Blattecke, 1967/2017, 232 x 174mm, offset print on cardboard, selling at Grisebach

Well, another post-’67 Blattecke just turned up for sale at Grisebach with a date of 11.2.2017. But in addition to the date, Richter puts the edition number on the corner of the turned up page. So by February 2017, the count was at 906.

What’s happened since?

Continue reading “There Are At Least 906 Blattecke”

Stanley Brouwn at Portal 5

an invitation card stamped with stanley brouwn/ 13-28 feb. 2025 on it, and some postal service scuff marks, for a show opening at portal 5 in tribeca

A Stanley Brouwn show does not happen every day, and even when it did, odds are you weren’t supposed to tell anyone about it.

But next week, Portal 5 in Tribeca will open a stanley brouwn: in a certain direction, organized by Timothy Y. Hill, of Jonathan A. Hill rare booksellers.

[a few days later update: greg.org hero Jack Murphy wrote about his visit to the show, which sounded like a banger.]

373 Broadway, Suite 511, the Tribeca Spaces Bldg below White and above Ricky’s. You want me to draw you a map? email timothy.y.hill@gmail.com for an appointment.

Sculptures of Music or Experience

an arc of steel rod extends down and off a white wall. it is studded with sculpey flower blossoms, painted blue, gradating from dark at the top to light at the end. each flower was made within the run time of a disco song the artist erik hanson liked when he was a punk dj, so a playlist—and the listening to it—as sculpture.
Erik Hanson, Disco Songs I Liked When I was a Punk Rock DJ, 2003, sculpey, epoxy, steel, oil paint 
36 x 10 x 16 inches, image via Derek Eller

Speaking of photographs of perfume, in the early 2000s artist Erik Hanson was making sculptures of music. The first one I saw was at White Columns; it was blue stalagmites. Hanson dripped plaster into a stalagmite for the duration of each track on a David Bowie album. The two album sides were made on separate boards, which were then joined, facing each other, into a little box-like cave.

After the study I saw at White Columns—I think it was Ziggy Stardust—Hanson did a show of Bowie’s discography as little caves at Derek Eller. They were elegant, esoteric sculptures whose process was evident, but whose system was embedded in the titles. I’m left writing about sculpture because I can’t find any images online. Hanson made spiral drawings and other sculptural forms with the same durational strategy; the resulting work indexes the artist’s subjective experience of listening—or of making while listening—to a song. The body of work, then, becomes a catalogue of formative musical experience: playlist as autobiography as form, like the 2003 cascade of sculpey flowers above, Disco Songs I Liked When I Was A Punk DJ.

an intricately tangled sculpture made of lengths of wood painted in different colors, formed improvisationally by taking the letters of a sentence of text as a score, and resulting in a knot of angles, kind of like how a dna strand is curled on itself. the sculpture is inside the closed off domed space at the top of a building at girard college in philadelphia, made by steve roden in 2009. rip
Steve Roden, Nothing But What Is Therein Contained…, 2009, installation view at Girard College, Phila.

This, along with Chris Rusak and Amelia Konow’s Lumen Prototypes, make me think back on the systemic works of Steve Roden. He would devise a scheme, seemingly but never arbitrary, more or less mathematical, subjective or convoluted, and set it in motion to produce one thing from another: text into sculpture, city into sound. One thing I’d forgotten him saying about his 2009 project in Philadelphia, Nothing But What Is Therein Contained, is the importance of intuition within the parameters of the system, as the point, even. And I’d forgotten it in 2009, too.

Perfumery and Photography Together

a silver gelatin photo, typically black and white, is here developed into a palette of pinks and browns by the lumen printing process. I think chemicals or substances used for perfume were applied in a grid of 4 x 3 spots, each interacting in a different way with the chemicals on the photo paper in a variety of ways. some are dark and fluid, some transparent, some two toned, some almost imperceptible. perhaps an experienced perfume photo maker will be able to determine the element from the type of mark it makes, but that is not me. one of several fragrance-based lumen prototypes by artists chris rusak and amelia konow.
Chris Rusak and Amelia Konow, Lumen Prototype, 2024, 10 x 8 in, unique gelatin silver print, via

Both perfume and photography involve chemical processes. And I think in their Lumen Prototypes, fragrance and photo conceptualists, respectively, Chris Rusak and Amelia Konow are exploring what a photograph of a fragrance could be.

At least that’s the sense I got from the little unique silver gelatin print, and the zine containing evocative essays from the artists, and Rusak’s newly released conceptual fragrances, which I just got as part of his yearlong Analog/Context project. [They’re also sold separately, and at larger scale, above.]

They chose lumen prints, an intricate chemical photographic technique that, like cyanotypes, are made in daylight without a camera. What I think is happening is that Rusak and Konow are capturing the visual expression of fragrances—either composed or in constituent parts, I am not sure, and they’re not saying. They’re both abstract and not: they clearly show traces of their making, or of their subject/materials: liquidity, flow, absorption, dilution, evaporation, color, density.

But that visual record still doesn’t reveal what anything smells like, what the experience is of the fragrance(s), the unfolding over time. That gap resonates with the herculean poetic struggle to explain a perfume—or a picture—in a way that approaches the sensory encounter with it. And even though I don’t know what fragrance I’m looking at, they’ve nevertheless made a picture of it.

Chris Rusak & Amelia Konow: Lumen Prototypes [chrisrusak.com]
Amelia Konow [ameliakonow.com]
Previously, related: Chris Rusak, HOME; Incense Sensibility

Riding Rail With Roe Ethridge & Mark Leckey

The Brooklyn Rail’s The New Social Environment is a daily artist conversation series, which is an incredibly ambitious amount of programming, but also the most natural-seeming thing in the world.

Anyway, tomorrow, Thursday, Feb. 6, Roe Ethridge will be talking about his current show at Andrew Kreps.

And on Monday, Feb. 10, Mark Leckey will be talking about his current show at Gladstone, which closes on the 15th.

They’re so quick with the uploads!

Registration is required, but free, though you could join me and donate to the Rail.

Unfinished Twombly Sculpture

OK, just one more.

a photo of cy twombly's painting studio in gaeta with supplies as he left them on rickety tables, and an unfinished sculpture-like tower of boxes in the center. the view of the bay out the windows is washed out by the exposure. manfredi gioacchini fecit.
Manfredi Gioacchini’s photo of Twombly’s studio in Gaeta, a corner room with views of the bay and the city scape, but those are washed out, so look at this sculpture-like stack on the rickety table.

What’s popping out to me as I keep looking at Manfredi Gioacchini’s photos of Twombly’s Gaeta house & studio is the sculptures everywhere, and things that look like sculptures. It’s the sculpture-like objects here, the things that look like they could become Twombly sculptures, that seem to show him thinking and living with objects in a certain way, not just sitting down and making them.

a detail from manfredi gioacchini's photo showing the unfinished sculpture in cy twombly's studio, a yellow round box of harrods savory biscuits, upside down on a white painted wood box. a green-topped pie plate looking thing is on that, wht these glove and stick, or rib and pouch or who knows what fetishy little objects are perched on top
a detail of the Harrod’s tin, the little things on top, img;

What got me thinking about all this was the little tower of white-painted wood box and upside-down Harrod’s biscuit box in Twombly’s corner studio. When Gioacchini photographed it, it had what I thought were paint brushes in cloths, but which turned out to be little fetish-like pouch & stick combos.

a screenshot of cy dear where the clutter of paint and brushes and an unfinished sculpture comprised of a little ziggurat of wood box, round biscuit tin, plate, and two spare rib-like plastery objects fill sawhorse tables in cy twombly's studio while the bay and fortress of gaeta are centered in the open window
me forced to take a photo of Cy Dear on my television like a savage to show that this unfinished sculpture-like object is still there in Twombly’s studio in 2017 onward

They’re also there in Cy Dear, which was released in 2019, but shot beginning, I think, in 2017. So perhaps a sculpture left unfinished in a studio that seems left largely as it was at Twombly’s death. I had somehow figured Gioacchini’s photos were from 2009, but it makes little sense that the studio would be untouched for two years before Twombly’s death. Now it looks like a deleted tweet announcing the photos came in November 2020, so three years after the documentary, not a decade before. The unfinished sculpture was still there, still unfinished.

Manfredi Gioacchini | Cy Twombly Gaeta [manfredigioacchini]
Gioacchini’s new book Grand Tour, published Oct. 2024 by Quodlibet, includes the Gaeta photos [manfredigioacchini]

What Are These Statues In Cy Twombly’s Library

manfredi gioacchini's photo along the open enfilade doorways of cy twombly's house in gaeta, where the library dominates between two sets of doors. along the left wall are tables and a pedestal with white classical sculptures on them, surrounded by crystals, shells, and other tchotchkes. beyond the library through the farther doors is what looks to be table with hats on it, and another door beyond that. the sculpture closest to the foreground was photographed head-on by tacita dean in 2008, and is the subject of this whole effort. though it is also interesting to look through all the photos gioacchini made for other details.
Manfredi Giaocchini, Cy Twombly Gaeta, c.2009 2020? via

I promise this site is not just a Cy Twombly fanblog, but after greg.org hero Claudio Santambrogio found a previously unknown photo of the artist’s house in Gaeta, I tracked it back to a whole previously unknown set of photos, made by World of Interiors contributor Manfredi Gioacchini in, I think, 2009. [next day update: I remembered this wrong; in a now-deleted tweet Gioacchini announced them as new in November 2020, so almost a decade after Twombly’s death.]

a plaster or white painted terra cotta statue of a male nude figure twisting to hold a tablet while billows of drapery surround him sits on a table in front of a wall of books in cy twombly's living room slash bedroom in gaeta. tacita dean made this photo in 2008 but did not publish it, though poet mary jacobus used it in a presentation, from whence this screengrab was made in 2023, in order to identify the statue.
screenshot from Mary Jacobus’s presentation on her Twombly book, via

What jumps out at me? Well, there are additional views of the (plaster? painted terra cotta?) statue Tacita Dean photographed in Twombly’s library, which I’d wondered about in December 2023. [It’s feeling harder and harder to claim this isn’t a fanblog…]

a dark interior and bright sunny window view in manfredi giaocchini's photo of cy twombly's library in gaeta. in the shadow, two white classical style sculptures stand, the arger one on a pedestal, on the left, and the shorter one, on a tchotchke-filled table, on the right. a dark tabletop in the foreground reflects a little sunlight, but is out of focus
mood lighting in Manfredi Gioacchini’s 2009 photo of Cy Twombly’s library/bedroom, via

Anyway, point is, the statue is one of three. Actually, there are more throughout Gioacchini’s photos of the house, but there are three in this library grouping. At the center, in front of the window, is a larger, dramatically unfinished twisting satyr or something. Maybe it’s leaning on an unfinished stump.

Whether they’re actually a pair, another similarly scaled male figure, with its arm raised, sits on a matching table. The contortion and billowing cloak/drapery make me think they’re connected. From the top photo, the 2023 sculpture in profile shows how deep the drapery goes, too. It would be unusual for this to be on a frieze or in a niche; these may be meant to stand free and be seen in the round. Though here Twombly has arranged them in a triptych, with his view of the bay behind.

[April 2025 update: While world’s going to hell, I went to the National Gallery library, where a quick turn through the photos of Twombly, Tacita Dean, and Sally Mann confirm that the large center statue in the Gaeta trio was the Pan statue Twombly often photographed in Bassano in Teverina. Here is a 1998 photo exhibited at Gagosian Roma in 2021, for example, that shows it in profile through a doorway.]

a color photocopy of a polaroid by cy twombly from 1998 of a plaster statue of pan perched or leaning on a tree stump or rock or something is atop a heavy, dark credenza or chest shaped furniture, lit from behind. the pale arms of a french style fauteuil are next to the cabinet, cropped by the heavy rustic dark wood door which frames the scene of the sculpture in the room behind it. behind the door, that is, not the sculpture. nicola del roscio has been named the copyright holder of all of twombly's photographic oeuvre, including this image, which was exhibited at gagosian in rome in 2021, but which is here used to confirm the identification of the statue, as one the artist later moved to gaeta, and to confirm that if people in twombly world have known of my public plea to identify the various plaster statues in his homes, they dgaf enough to reach out and say oh yeah, that's the pan from bassano or whatever, but that's fine. at this point i'm appreciating the inquiry as much as the answer. keeps me looking.
Cy Twombly, Interior, 1998, Bassano in Teverina, drypoint, ed. 6, shown by the esteemed copyrightholder of the entire oeuvre, Fondazione Nicola Del Roscio, at Gagosian Roma in 2021

Previously, directly related: What Is This Statue in Cy Twombly’s Library?
Manfredi Gioacchini | Cy Twombly Gaeta [manfredigioacchini]
Gioacchini’s new book Grand Tour, published Oct. 2024 by Quodlibet, includes the Gaeta photos [manfredigioacchini]

Gagosian’s First Show At 980 Madison Was Not Cy Twombly

Now that Gagosian is closing their 980 Madison Avenue space with a Twombly show, the line has gone around that it makes sense, because Gagosian always opened a new space with a Twombly show. But 980 Madison did not open with a Twombly show. It opened with a Jasper Johns show.

Jasper Johns: The Maps was Gagosian’s first show at 980 Madison Avenue. It opened 36 years ago today: February 3rd, 1989. Before that, Gagosian, sometimes called “a Los Angeles dealer” in reviews, had a space in Chelsea, at 521 West 23rd St. The first Cy Twombly exhibition at 980, Bolsena Paintings, opened in December 1989. Twombly’s exhibition history includes a show at Gagosian NY in 1986, which is not in Gagosian’s exhibition archive [indeed, none of the W 23rd St shows are.] In the three-year interim, Twombly showed new and old work with five other New York galleries.

Continue reading “Gagosian’s First Show At 980 Madison Was Not Cy Twombly”